There are many great rivalries in sports, Duke/North Carolina in college basketball, Michigan/Ohio St in college football, Red Sox/Yankees in baseball and of course France/conflict. I am a fan of three of these, Duke, the Red Sox and conflict. Being a fan of any of these you quickly learn to have a dislike for anyone on the other side. There may only be one exception to this and that is Mickey Mantle.

Yesterday my Dad, the reason I am a Red Sox fan, and I shared a few emails about this subject and since he grew up when the Mick was the most popular athlete of the day he agreed. Mickey is a big reason why so many boomers are fans of the Yankees. My father-in-law is a great example. He has lived his whole life in Indiana and it is because of Mantle he became a Yankee fan. There was just something about the country boy from Oklahoma who hit the towering home runs that appealed to people, kids especially.
After DiMaggio and his “sparkling” personality retired, Mickey Mantle became the center fielder for the Yankees. Of course he had a lot to live up to because some people will tell you that DiMaggio was the greatest player since Ruth, of course this is wrong. DiMaggio could not hold a candle to Ted Williams. Mantle struggled early in the New York spotlight and the shadow of the player he replaced. But he succeeded of course and was the center piece of another Yankee dynasty.
So why do I like Mickey Mantle even though he played for the hated Yankees? Well one I had not been born yet. The second one is how bad the Red Sox were in the ’50s and ’60s when Mantle was at his peak, he was not part of Yankee teams that inflicted pain like the teams in 1949 and 1950. Because of this the bad talk about him from Red Sox fans does not seem as great as it is for DiMaggio, Bucky Dent, Aaron Boone and of course A-Rod. The third is the “what might have been?” question about Mickey’s career. Just about every season in his career was affected by injury. If he had been healthy his whole career, his numbers would be astronomical and no steroid taking former lead-off hitter would come close to approaching his home run totals. The fourth is what happened after his career. The years of hard living affected Mantle and he had to seek treatment for alcoholism and eventually had to have a liver transplant. He also became a born-again Christian and in the last year of his life he apologized countless times for the way he acted as a young man. Bob Costas gave the eulogy at Mantle’s funeral and I think he hits it when talking about a hero and role model:
“In the last year of his life, Mickey Mantle, always so hard on himself, finally came to accept and appreciate the distinction between a role model and a hero. The first, he often was not. The second, he always will be. And, in the end, people got it.“
So there you go a die-hard Red Sox fan admitting to liking a Yankee, but like I said can you really not like Mickey Mantle?
Recent Comments